Pipeline-ETL: CAD (BIM) project verification
26 February 2024Validation of human requirements in life
26 February 2024In the mid-2000s the construction industry encountered an unprecedented challenge due to the rapid expansion of data in data management and processing systems, particularly those originating from CAD (BIM) departments. This surge in data volume caught company executives and managers off guard, leaving them unprepared for the growing data quality and data management requirements.
Taking advantage of the lack of open data & open solutions and limited competition in the data processing market, and using marketing campaigns related to the new acronym BIM from CAD (BIM) vendors, new organisations have begun to create new standards and concepts that de jure should be aimed at improving data management practices.
While almost all initiatives directly or indirectly supported by CAD (BIM) vendors have focused on optimizing workflows, they have resulted in a plethora of standards lobbied by various stakeholders, leading the construction industry to some ambiguity and confusion about data processes.
Let's list some of the new data standards that have emerged over the last years in the construction industry:
- BEP (BIM Execution Plan) describes how to integrate and utilize CAD (BIM) in a project by defining data handling methods and processes.
- EIR / AIA (Employer's Information Requirements) document, which is prepared by the client prior to the invitation to tender and contains the requirements for the contractor with regard to the preparation and delivery of information. It serves as the basis for the BEP in the respective project.
- AIM (Asset Information Model) - As part of the BIM process. Once the project is handed over and completed, the data model is called the "Asset Information Model" or AIM. The purpose of the AIM is to manage, maintain and operate the realized asset.
- IDS (Information Delivery Specification) determines what data and in what format is required at different stages of a construction project.
- LOD (Level Of Detail) indicates the level of detail of the CAD (BIM) model at different stages of design.
- APS (Autodesk® Platform Services) and similar tools from closed application vendors, describes the tools and infrastructure from CAD (BIM) vendors needed to create linked and open data models.
Most of the new concepts in the field of data handling in the construction industry offer a variety of approaches that must be harmonized with the marketing strategies of CAD vendors using BIM (Building Information Modeling). As a result, the concepts and some of the existing construction industry standards developed and promoted by interested companies in the last decades are often found to be redundant or even counterproductive in business processes. Instead of simplifying data processing, they create additional complexities.
Most of the new data requirements in the construction industry describe entity attributes and their boundary values through various standards that have tables at their core
One of the latest examples of new concepts is the IDS format, which allows to describe the requirements for the attribute composition of an information model - it creates information on attributes and their boundary values in a structured table form, which is then translated into XML format markup, which is called the IDS format.
As a result, the construction industry is coming up with more and more new ideas for data control and management every year, overlooking the fact that data in construction projects is no different from data in other industries, and that other industries, having uniform data processing methods, do not need similar requirements and concepts.
Although CAD (BIM) tool developers may give the impression of uniqueness in handling data in the construction, in reality the construction industry does not stand out with special information processing requirements compared to other industries.
The number of requirements for projects and CAD (BIM) formats can be simplified by using a unified requirements table with attribute-columns, described in detail in the chapter "Translating Requirements into Structured Form", without having to translate the originally structured requirements into non-table formats.
A simplified approach that includes columns for identifier, property, and validation rules bypasses the need to convert requirements to IDS-XML or COBie format, offering a direct and less cumbersome way to ensure data quality. A simplified structured requirements structure includes the basic attributes and the required level of detail: the grouping data attribute (Type or Category), the names of the attributes to be checked and their boundary values.
Data requirements in the construction industry can be simplified to a tabular structure covering the type of entity attributes and their level of detail
The methods and tools used to collect, prepare and analyze data in construction should not be fundamentally different from those used by professionals in other sectors of the economy.
While concepts and marketing acronyms come and go, the data requirements validation processes themselves will forever be an integral part of corporate processes, just as requirements and validation affect the daily lives of the people who make decisions based on old and new incoming information on a daily basis.
